East Haven Tavern Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to East Haven Tavern, where the heart of New Haven’s culinary scene beats strong. Nestled at 635 Green St, this cozy tavern invites you to indulge in a menu brimming with flavor and comfort. The highlight here is undoubtedly the Jalapeno Burger Basket, featuring a kickin’ quarter-pound patty topped with grilled onions and pepper jack cheese, all for just $12.99. If you’re in the mood for something a bit different, try the renowned Philly sandwich or our Bleu Cheese Burger, praised for its smoky bacon and creamy cheese blend.
- Customer favorites include:
- Delicious cheese curds and garlic mushrooms – a delightful starter.
- The attentive service that makes every visit special.
- Casual atmosphere, perfect for a relaxing meal with friends.
Be sure to sip on their Hot Butter Rum for a warm, comforting touch to your meal. Experience the charm and great food that makes East Haven Tavern a local gem!
Starters
Gizzards – “Best Seller”
Oh so tender! Slow cooked, deep fried to order in a zesty batter.
Gizzards – “Best Seller” Basket
Oh so tender! Slow cooked, deep fried to order in a zesty ubatter., Includes fries and cold side.
Chicken Tenders
Breaded or battered crispy chicken.
Chicken Tenders Basket
Includes fries and cold side.
Mini Chicken Tacos
Folded tortilla with a variety of fillings such as meat or beans.
Pepper Jack Cheese Balls
Onion Petals
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried.
Pretzels And Cheese
2 pieces.
Crinkle French Fries
Fried potatoes.
Deep Fried Pickles
Hand battered and deep fried dill pickles. Served with our homemade Ranch dressing
Add Warm Cheese Sauce
Chef Salad
-Lettuce, tomato, colby cheese, bacon, egg, smoked ham and turkey breast.
Chef Wrap
-Lettuce, tomato, colby cheese, bacon, egg, smoked ham and turkey breast.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Lettuce, chicken breast, tossed in mild sauce, tomato and mozzarella cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Lettuce, chicken breast, tossed in mild sauce, tomato and mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Lettuce, tomato, chicken breast, ranch, Colby cheese and crumbled bacon.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, chicken breast, ranch, Colby cheese and crumbled bacon.
Salads and Wraps
Sammys and Burgers
Fried Bologna Sammy
Thick sliced, down-home bologna. Deep fried and served on a toasted bun.
Fried Bologna Sammy Basket
Thick sliced, down-home bologna. Deep fried and served on a toasted bun.
Philly Sammy
Philly steak, covered in grilled onions and green peppers and Swiss
Philly Sammy Basket
Philly steak, covered in grilled onions and green peppers and Swiss
Tenderloin Sammy
Delicious-1 of our best sellers! grilled or breaded.
Tenderloin Sammy Basket
Delicious-1 of our best sellers! grilled or breaded.
Ham And Swiss Sammy
Fresh deli ham covered in melted swiss cheese, served on a toasted hoagie bun.
Ham And Swiss Sammy Basket
Fresh deli ham covered in melted swiss cheese, served on a toasted hoagie bun.
Cheese Griller Sammy
Pepper jack, Swiss and American cheese on Texas toast.
Cheese Griller Sammy Basket
Pepper jack, Swiss and American cheese on Texas toast.
Chicken Breast Sammy
Grilled or breaded - fresh chicken grilled or breaded to order, served on a toasted Hoagie bun.
Chicken Breast Sammy Basket
Grilled or breaded - fresh chicken grilled or breaded to order, served on a toasted Hoagie bun.
Cheeseburger
Quarter lb. patty with pepper jack, Swiss or American cheese.
Cheeseburger Basket
Quarter lb. patty with pepper jack, Swiss or American cheese.
Mushroom And Swiss Sammy
Quarter lb. patty smothered in fresh buttery mushrooms and Swiss.
Mushroom And Swiss Sammy Basket
Quarter lb. patty smothered in fresh buttery mushrooms and Swiss.
Patty Melt
Quarter lb. patty, smothered in grilled onion and Swiss, served on toasted rye.
Patty Melt Basket
Quarter lb. patty, smothered in grilled onion and Swiss, served on toasted rye.
Bleu Cheese Burger
Quarter lb. patty, topped with bacon, Swiss and a blend of bleu cheese.
Bleu Cheese Burger Basket
Quarter lb. patty, topped with bacon, Swiss and a blend of bleu cheese.
Jalapeno Burger
Quarter lb. patty, grilled with kickin’ spices, smothered in grilled onion, jalapenos and pepper jack cheeses.
Jalapeno Burger Basket
Quarter lb. patty, grilled with kickin’ spices, smothered in grilled onion, jalapenos and pepper jack cheeses.
East Haven Burger
2 patties, American cheese topped with fresh slaw.
East Haven Burger Basket
2 patties, American cheese topped with fresh slaw.